Also heads up to everyone, for whatever reason, the plugin extension didn't work with any tabs that were opened prior to the install of the extension. I would get the reload tab message, and reloading would just have it ask again.
The solution that worked is to just close the tab, open the same website up in a new tab and now it would work. I replicated this a few times and it seems that no matter how times you reload or navigate around, any tabs that were open before I installed the extension didn't work until I closed them, then it worked ever since.
So my advice is to just restart the browser after installing the extension. With a fresh browser, then all the tabs will recognize the extension and have worked for me ever since. I have tested it on about 25 or so different websites and so far it has worked on everything after the browser restart. And it has worked across multiple restarts too.