6

The purpose of this suggestion:
On December 22, 2024, a YouTube channel MegaLag published a video about the deceptive and predatory ways Honey operates.

Here's a summary of the video by Kagi Universal Summarizer (emphasis mine):

  • The video reveals that Honey, a browser extension owned by PayPal, is accused of deceiving consumers and influencers by misrepresenting its ability to find coupon codes.
  • Influencers promoting Honey were largely unaware that the extension was undermining their affiliate commissions, potentially costing content creators millions.
  • Honey employs a mechanism where it replaces affiliate tracking cookies with its own, claiming credit for sales that it did not actually refer, thus stealing commissions from influencers.
  • The video outlines three scenarios showcasing how Honey manipulates affiliate commissions, highlighting the unethical practices within its operations.
  • Honey's business model relies on "last click attribution," allowing it to capture sales credits at the final purchasing stage, making it difficult for other affiliates to compete.
  • The investigation found that Honey often fails to find the best coupon codes, and instead promotes codes that are controlled by partner stores, undermining its promise to consumers.
  • Honey has sponsored nearly 5,000 videos across various YouTube channels, leading to widespread promotion of its services based on misleading claims.
  • The Better Business Bureau investigated Honey's advertising claims but dropped the case after Honey ceased its misleading statements for unspecified business reasons.
  • The video highlights a disturbing pattern of Honey’s practices leading to increased prices for consumers due to the commission cuts taken from businesses.

The investigation in the video appears thorough and I have no reason to doubt any of the things discovered.

Currently, Orion lists Honey in its Popular Extensions list under Browse Better

Why this change is needed:
While the users ultimately have the ability to choose which extensions they use, I don't think Honey should be highlighted in the Popular Extensions section. Additionally, the inclusion of a harmful, anti-consumer extension like Honey clashes with Kagi's stance on advertising and tracking.

    5 days later
    2 months later
    No one is typing